Research shows that electric pulse collars are no more effective than methods of positive reinforcement.

Consultation raises a number of welfare concerns

British vets are calling for a complete ban on the use and sale of electric pulse collars.

The BVA and the BSAVA made the appeal following a Scottish Government consultation on the use of electronic training aids which raised a number of welfare concerns.

Until further research is completed, the organisations are demanding regulation around the sale and manufacture of the collars to ensure that pet owners are made aware of their harmful affects.

“Electronic training devices, such as electric pulse collars, have a negative, painful effect on dogs and can cause them unnecessary suffering,” says Grace Webster, president of the BVA Scottish Branch.

“We know from our own experience and expertise, and consultation with leading veterinary behaviourists, that using fear as a training tool is less effective than positive reinforcement and can instead take a toll on the dog’s overall welfare.

“Further to this, it is too easy to purchase one of these devices and despite good guidance and manuals, these are often not read fully, leaving the devices open to misuse in the wrong hands.”

Electric pulse devices are sometimes used in dog training as a form of punishment, yet research shows that electric pulse collars are no more effective than methods of positive reinforcement.

The consultation was released in November 2015 in response to a number of requests for electric shock and vibration collars to be banned in Scotland.